MENU
MENU

When the Holidays Remind You of What's Missing

Nov 19, 2024

There's something about the holidays that can make the distance between the life we have and the life we imagined feel particularly noticeable. Maybe you're decorating a Christmas tree alone for the first time in years. Maybe you're trying to figure out how to divide Thanksgiving between two households now that you're divorced. Maybe you're looking at the empty chair where someone you loved used to sit. Or perhaps you're surrounded by family, participating in all the familiar traditions, and feeling a sadness you can't quite explain.

The holidays come with a lot of expectations about how we're supposed to feel. We're surrounded by images of happy families, loving couples, crowded dinner tables, and traditions that seem to bring everyone together. Even when we know those images don't tell the whole story, they can remind us of something we miss or wish were different. And when our own circumstances don't match what the season seems to promise, the contrast can be painful.

I think we tend to associate grief primarily with death, but there are so many other losses people carry. A marriage ends. A relationship changes. A friendship fades. An adult child becomes distant. A parent is still alive but no longer capable of being the parent we need. A family that once gathered together now celebrates in separate homes. Sometimes the loss is less visible. We're grieving the closeness we thought we'd have with our spouse, the family relationships we hoped would improve, or the future we imagined for ourselves that hasn't materialized.

These losses don't always receive the same recognition as bereavement, but that doesn't make them less meaningful. And the holidays can bring them into focus because so much of the season is organized around relationships, belonging, and the idea of being together.

Consider someone going through a divorce. They may be doing reasonably well, finding their footing, establishing new routines, and even feeling confident that ending the marriage was the right decision. Then the holidays arrive, and suddenly they're negotiating where the children will spend Christmas morning, deciding whether to attend a party they used to go to as a couple, or realizing that a tradition they loved no longer belongs to them in quite the same way.

They may find themselves missing parts of a relationship they don't actually want back.

I think that can be confusing for people. They assume that if they're grieving something, it must mean they made the wrong decision or haven't moved on. But we can grieve the loss of something meaningful without wanting to return to the circumstances in which it existed. We can miss the traditions, the familiarity, the shared history, or the version of our family that once existed while still knowing that the relationship itself needed to end.

The same complexity can exist when the relationship hasn't ended. Someone may be married and spending the holidays with their spouse but feeling lonely within the relationship. Someone may attend a family gathering knowing that certain subjects can't be discussed or that they'll once again be expected to occupy a role they've spent years trying to outgrow. Someone may long for a warmer relationship with a parent or sibling and find themselves disappointed, yet again, when the holiday doesn't bring the closeness they hoped for.

Sometimes we're grieving something that never really existed in the first place. The easy family gatherings, the emotionally available parent, the partner who enjoys making the holidays special, or the sense of belonging we've always wanted. There's a particular sadness in recognizing that the holiday experience we keep hoping for may not be something the people in our lives are capable of creating with us.

And of course, there is the grief of losing someone to death. The first holiday without them can be especially difficult, but grief doesn't follow a calendar. Years later, a familiar song, a favorite recipe, or an ordinary moment at the dinner table can bring someone back into focus. The absence may become more familiar over time without becoming unimportant.

What all of these experiences have in common is that the holidays can confront us with change, and change often requires some form of grieving. We have to make room for the fact that something is different, whether we wanted that difference or not.

I think one of the harder parts is deciding what to do with traditions. Traditions are comforting partly because they're predictable. We know where we're going, who will be there, what we'll eat, and how the day will unfold. But when relationships change, those familiar arrangements can become painful reminders of what we've lost. We may feel pressure to preserve everything exactly as it was, particularly when children or extended family members are involved, even though the circumstances that made those traditions meaningful have changed.

I would encourage people to become curious about which traditions still feel good and which ones they're maintaining primarily out of obligation, guilt, or fear of disappointing someone. You don't necessarily have to abandon a tradition because the relationship associated with it has changed. But you also don't have to keep recreating an experience that no longer fits your life.

Perhaps you continue making a favorite holiday meal but invite different people to share it. Maybe you decide that this year you won't host everyone. Perhaps you celebrate with your children on a different day rather than trying to compete over the exact holiday. Or maybe you choose to spend a quieter day with one or two people instead of attending a large family gathering that leaves you feeling depleted.

The important part is giving yourself permission to reconsider what you're doing and why.

I also think it helps to be realistic about what the holidays can and cannot accomplish for our relationships. We sometimes place an enormous amount of hope on a particular gathering. Maybe this will be the year everyone gets along. Maybe my sibling will finally make an effort. Maybe my partner will recognize how important this is to me. Maybe my parents will behave differently now that we're all adults.

Hope is understandable, but when we repeatedly expect a holiday to repair something that hasn't been addressed throughout the year, we may be setting ourselves up for another painful disappointment.

Sometimes a more useful question is, Given what I know about these relationships, what would make this holiday feel manageable and meaningful for me? That doesn't mean giving up on people or deciding they can never change. It means making plans based on the relationships we actually have rather than relying entirely on the ones we wish we had.

There may also be conversations worth having before the holidays arrive. If you're newly divorced, perhaps you and your former partner need to clarify plans early enough that the children aren't caught in the middle. If you're dreading time with extended family, perhaps you and your spouse need to discuss what support would look like for each of you. If you're grieving someone who has died, you might tell the people closest to you whether you'd like to talk about that person, include a familiar tradition, or simply have the freedom to step away when you need to.

These conversations won't remove the sadness, but they can reduce the additional strain of unspoken expectations.

And I would encourage people to pay attention to the difference between choosing solitude and withdrawing because they're hurting. There may be years when a quiet holiday is exactly what you need. You don't have to attend every gathering or surround yourself with people simply because the calendar says you should. But if you find yourself avoiding everyone because you feel ashamed, unwanted, or unable to tolerate seeing other people happy, it may be worth reaching toward someone you trust. You don't have to pretend you're feeling festive to deserve company.

There's also room for enjoyment, even when you're grieving. I think people sometimes feel conflicted when they have a good moment during a difficult season. They laugh at dinner, enjoy a party, or find themselves looking forward to something and then feel guilty, as though happiness means the loss matters less. But enjoying part of the holiday doesn't erase what you're missing. We can experience sadness and pleasure in the same season, sometimes even in the same afternoon.

What I wouldn't want is for someone to spend the entire holiday measuring how well they're handling it. You don't need to prove that you've moved on, that you're happy with your circumstances, or that you've successfully created a new life. You also don't need to make the season entirely about your loss. There can be room for what hurts and for what still feels good.

As the holidays approach, I think it's worth asking yourself what you're bringing into the season. Are you missing someone? Are you grieving a relationship that has changed? Are you disappointed by a family dynamic you can't seem to improve? Are you holding on to a tradition because it still brings you joy, or because letting it change would mean acknowledging something you're not quite ready to accept?

You may not be able to change the circumstances that make this holiday different. You may not be able to bring someone back, restore a relationship, or create the family experience you've always wanted. But you can make thoughtful choices about how you participate, what you ask of yourself, and where you look for connection.

The holidays don't have to look the way they used to in order to hold something meaningful. And they don't have to feel entirely happy to be worth participating in. Sometimes the work is allowing yourself to miss what was, acknowledge what isn't, and remain open to what might still be possible.

View more insights

SCROLL FOR MORE >

Don't Wait Until You're Fighting to Have the Conversation

By the time some couples finally have an evening to themselves, the last thing either person wants is another difficult conversation. They've spent the day...
READ MORE

Is There Something Wrong With Me?

There are questions we ask because we want information, and there are questions that sound like questions but already contain a conclusion. Is there something...
READ MORE

Is It Me, Is It You, or Is It Us?

Maybe you’ve been questioning your relationship for a while, but every time you think you know what the problem is, you change your mind. You...
READ MORE

What If the Thing You Keep Asking For Never Comes?

There are things we want from the people we love that may never come in quite the way we hoped. Maybe you wish your partner...
READ MORE

Healing When You Still Don’t Understand What Happened

There is a particular kind of agony in having a relationship end without understanding why. You replay the last conversation, go back through old text...
READ MORE

Can You Love a Person and Not Accept Their Behavior?

Sometimes staying connected to someone we love requires us to hold two very different truths about them. We can know that a parent loves us...
READ MORE

When You and Your Partner See Family Differently

When two people build a life together, they aren't really starting with a blank slate. Each person arrives with a whole family culture behind them....
READ MORE

If I Have to Ask for It, Does It Still Count?

Imagine you have told your partner more than once that it means a lot to you when they initiate plans for the two of you....
READ MORE

The Hardest Part of a Conversation Isn't Talking

Something I hear fairly often from couples, especially early in therapy, is, “I don’t want to come here just to fight.” Sometimes only one partner...
READ MORE
CLIENT PORTAL
CLIENT PORTAL
crossmenu