MENU
MENU

Are We Incompatible or Overwhelmed?

May 11, 2026

I recently came across a line that stayed with me: “Modern couples struggle more with capacity than compatibility.” The more I thought about it, the more true it felt in the work I do with couples.

Many people come into therapy worried they may not be compatible anymore. They look at the tension, the disconnection, the irritability, the lack of intimacy, and they assume it must mean something fundamental is wrong between them. Sometimes compatibility truly is an issue. But more often than people realize, I see couples who genuinely love each other and want similar things, yet they are operating with very little emotional capacity left. And that changes everything.

When people are depleted, overwhelmed, stressed, underslept, overextended, anxious, grieving, parenting young children, caring for aging parents, navigating financial pressure, or simply trying to survive the pace of modern life, their ability to show up well in relationships narrows. Not because they do not care. Because they are full.

I often sit with couples who describe feeling disconnected from each other, but when we slow down and look at the context surrounding the relationship, it becomes clear that the relationship itself is carrying the weight of too many things.

For example, I might work with a couple who both deeply value family connection and partnership. They genuinely like each other. They both want a calm home and a strong marriage. But they are raising two young children, sleeping poorly, balancing demanding jobs, worrying about finances, and trying to manage endless logistical responsibilities.

Then one night, one partner says sharply, “You didn’t help me at all tonight.” The other immediately becomes defensive. “That’s not fair. I’ve been going nonstop all day too.”

Now the couple starts questioning the relationship itself.

But when we slow it down, what I often see is not two incompatible people. I see two overwhelmed people whose nervous systems no longer have much room left for patience, generosity, softness, or perspective.

When capacity is low, small things feel big. Neutral comments sound critical. Requests feel like demands. Differences feel threatening instead of manageable.

In those moments, couples often begin turning toward the wrong question. Instead of asking, “What’s happening to us?” it can be more helpful to ask, “What’s happening around us and inside us that is making it harder to access each other?”

That shift matters.

Because when couples interpret every struggle as evidence of incompatibility, hopelessness grows quickly. They start viewing each other through a lens of disappointment and deficiency rather than context.

But context changes how we understand behavior.

A partner who seems withdrawn may actually be emotionally exhausted. A partner who seems irritable may be carrying more anxiety than they realize. A couple who no longer feels playful may not have enough margin in their lives to access that part of themselves right now.

This does not mean couples should ignore harmful dynamics or excuse poor behavior. Capacity is not a free pass. But I do think many couples underestimate how much chronic stress impacts the way they relate to one another.

I also think modern relationships are being asked to carry an enormous amount. Today, we often expect our partner to be our emotional support system, best friend, co-parent, romantic partner, teammate, confidant, and source of stability while both people are simultaneously trying to keep up with the demands of everyday life.

That is a lot for two human beings.

One of the most important things couples can begin doing is learning how to recognize when the problem is not simply the content of the argument, but the condition of the people having it. Sometimes the conversation about dishes is not really about dishes. It is about two depleted people whose capacity has been stretched too thin.

When couples begin to understand this, it can soften the way they see each other. Instead of immediately assuming bad intent, they become more curious about what their partner may be carrying. Instead of escalating quickly, they may pause and recognize, “We are both overwhelmed right now.”

That awareness alone can change the tone of an interaction.

It can also help couples make more intentional choices about how they protect their relationship. Sometimes the work is not only improving communication. Sometimes it is creating more rest, more support, more boundaries, more recovery, more realistic expectations, and more space to actually be human together.

I often tell couples that relationships function very differently when people have emotional margin. When people feel regulated and supported, they are more patient, more generous, more flexible, and more capable of giving their partner the benefit of the doubt.

Capacity changes how love feels.

So if you and your partner have been feeling stuck lately, I would encourage you not to rush immediately toward the conclusion that you are incompatible. Pause first and ask yourselves a different question.

Do we have the emotional capacity right now to show up for each other in the ways we want to?

Sometimes that question opens the door to a much more compassionate understanding of what is actually happening in the relationship.

View more insights

SCROLL FOR MORE >

Why So Many Couples Think Something Is Wrong When Their Relationship Changes

One of the things I find myself normalizing often with couples is that relationships are not static. They change over time. The feelings shift. The...
READ MORE

Zoom Lens vs. Wide Lens: A Shift That Changes Everything

Why perspective might be the most important shift you can make There is something I say often to clients, especially when they feel overwhelmed or...
READ MORE

When You’re Arguing But Actually Agreeing

There is a phrase I use in sessions that often gets a pause and a head nod from both partners. I call it violent agreement....
READ MORE

Why Do I Feel Responsible for Everyone Else’s Emotions?

There is a pattern I see often in the therapy room that can be hard to recognize in yourself because, on the surface, it looks...
READ MORE

Why the Same Patterns Keep Showing Up in Your Relationship

There is something I find myself explaining often in sessions, and I want to put it into words in a way that feels simple and...
READ MORE

It Feels Like They’re "Making" You Feel This Way But There’s More to It

When Control Replaces Regulation I recently came across a line that stayed with me: “When people can’t regulate their emotions, they try to control other...
READ MORE

The Shift That Helps You Feel More Understood

Do you like being sold something hard by someone? The kind of interaction where you can feel the other person trying to convince you. Their...
READ MORE

Who’s Running the Meeting in Your Mind?

In therapy, people often describe feeling pulled in different directions. Part of them wants to speak up.Part of them wants to stay quiet.Part of them...
READ MORE

The Unexpected Wisdom in a Funny T-Shirt

A friend recently sent me a picture of her daughter wearing a T-shirt that made me laugh out loud. It said: “Hang in there. It...
READ MORE
CLIENT PORTAL
CLIENT PORTAL
crossmenu