MENU
MENU

When You’re Arguing But Actually Agreeing

Apr 25, 2026

There is a phrase I use in sessions that often gets a pause and a head nod from both partners.

I call it violent agreement.

What I mean by that is simple. You both want the same thing, but the way you are going about it makes you feel like opponents.

When couples are in the middle of a conflict, it rarely feels that way. It feels like one person is right and the other is wrong. One person is being reasonable and the other just doesn’t get it. The focus stays on the difference in approach, and it becomes easy to lose sight of the shared goal underneath it.

But when we slow things down, something different often emerges.

I might say, “I want to point something out. It sounds like you both actually want the same outcome here, but you’re going about it in very different ways. And in that difference, you’ve started to experience each other as opposition. I call that violent agreement.”

That moment can shift the room.

Because instead of seeing each other as the problem, you begin to see that you are both fighting for something that matters to you. The conflict is not about whether you care. It is about how you are trying to make that care visible.

This shows up in everyday situations.

Take something like a bedtime routine. Both parents might want the same thing. A smooth, calm transition at the end of the day. They both want their child to feel settled and to go to sleep without stress.

But one parent might approach this with structure and consistency. They want a clear routine, firm boundaries, and predictability. The other parent might approach it with flexibility and connection. They want the child to feel emotionally supported, even if that means extending the routine a bit.

Now the disagreement begins.

One partner sees the other as too rigid. The other sees their partner as too lenient. Each begins to believe the other is getting in the way of what they are trying to create.

And yet, underneath it, they both want the same thing. A peaceful bedtime.

The more they argue about the method, the more they lose sight of the shared intention.

This is violent agreement.

It feels like conflict, but there is actually alignment underneath it.

I see this pattern in many areas of relationships. Couples who both want to feel close, but one pursues connection through conversation while the other seeks it through space and calm. Couples who both care deeply about financial security, but one focuses on saving and the other on investing or growth. Couples who both want a strong partnership, but express that desire in ways that don’t immediately match.

When we don’t recognize the shared goal, the relationship can start to feel adversarial.

When we do recognize it, something softens.

There is often a sense of relief in realizing, “You’re not against me. You’re trying to get to the same place, just in a different way.”

That recognition does not solve the disagreement. You still have to work through how you want to approach things together. But it changes the tone of the conversation.

You move from opposition to collaboration.

So how do you begin to use this in your own relationship?

The first step is to pause and ask a different question in the middle of conflict. Instead of focusing only on what you disagree about, ask yourself, “What might we both be trying to create here?”

Sometimes the answer is clearer than you expect. You both want respect. You both want stability. You both want your child to feel secure. You both want the relationship to work.

The second step is to name that out loud.

You might say something like, “I think we actually want the same thing here. I think we both want bedtime to feel calm. We just have different ideas about how to get there.”

Naming the shared goal can immediately reduce the sense of threat in the conversation.

The third step is to stay curious about the difference instead of trying to eliminate it. Instead of arguing for your approach, you might ask, “Can you help me understand what feels important about the way you’re thinking about this?”

That kind of curiosity invites your partner to share the meaning behind their approach, not just defend it.

Over time, couples can begin to hold both things at once. The shared intention and the different strategies. From there, it becomes easier to find a way forward that incorporates both perspectives.

What I want couples to understand is that conflict is not always a sign that something is wrong in the relationship. Sometimes it is a sign that both people care deeply about something and are trying, in their own way, to protect or create it.

Violent agreement is not a problem to eliminate. It is something to recognize.

Because hidden inside it is common ground.

And common ground is often where change begins.

View more insights

SCROLL FOR MORE >

Why Do I Feel Responsible for Everyone Else’s Emotions?

There is a pattern I see often in the therapy room that can be hard to recognize in yourself because, on the surface, it looks...
READ MORE

Why the Same Patterns Keep Showing Up in Your Relationship

There is something I find myself explaining often in sessions, and I want to put it into words in a way that feels simple and...
READ MORE

It Feels Like They’re "Making" You Feel This Way But There’s More to It

When Control Replaces Regulation I recently came across a line that stayed with me: “When people can’t regulate their emotions, they try to control other...
READ MORE

The Shift That Helps You Feel More Understood

Do you like being sold something hard by someone? The kind of interaction where you can feel the other person trying to convince you. Their...
READ MORE

Who’s Running the Meeting in Your Mind?

In therapy, people often describe feeling pulled in different directions. Part of them wants to speak up.Part of them wants to stay quiet.Part of them...
READ MORE

The Unexpected Wisdom in a Funny T-Shirt

A friend recently sent me a picture of her daughter wearing a T-shirt that made me laugh out loud. It said: “Hang in there. It...
READ MORE

Why Letting Go After Betrayal Can Feel So Hard

One of the things I often hear from people after a deep betrayal is something like this: “I want to move on. I want to...
READ MORE

The Conversation Beneath the Conversation

One of the most interesting things about working with couples is that the argument people bring into the room is rarely the whole story. A...
READ MORE

You Don’t Have to Fix Your Feelings to Move Forward

“When you stop trying to fix your thoughts and eliminate discomfort and instead focus on how to move forward with those experiences, something shifts. You...
READ MORE
CLIENT PORTAL
CLIENT PORTAL
crossmenu